Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria Menu (Updated September 2025)

Welcome to Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria, a treasured gem nestled in Rochester, NY, where the essence of traditional Italian pizza meets contemporary culinary creativity. Located at 149 East Ridge Road, this eatery stands out not just for its food, but also for its inviting atmosphere, personalized service, and community engagement.

The menu is a delightful exploration of flavors, featuring the Famous Make Your Own Pizza Kit for just $12.00, allowing you to craft a masterpiece topped with rich mozzarella and a choice of toppings. Vegetables like mushrooms, spinach, and artichokes complement hearty options like pepperoni and Genoa salami, as acclaimed by customers like Abigail Peña, who praises the “juicy, warm, and amazing” pizzas.

  • Unique Offerings: Don’t miss the new Pizza Bowl, perfect for those seeking a dough-free delight.
  • Pub Burgers: Satisfy your cravings with options like the Italian Burger or the classic Double Cheeseburger.
  • Customer Experience: Rave reviews highlight exceptional service, with staff such as Natalie proving memorable connections that keep diners coming back.

Overall, Salvatore's combines a rich menu with a warm, familial ambiance, ensuring every visit is a celebration of flavor and community.

Extra Menu Picks